Ten points, three goals, and something to chase

James Garner curling one in, Hayden Hackney arriving in the box, Thierno Barry finishing the job. Everton’s 3–1 cup win over Newcastle on Thursday gave us three goals from three players and something better to discuss than another respectable defeat. Fleetwood away stands between us and a League Cup semi-final. That is a proper thing to want.

It also leaves the league record exactly where it was: eight games, two wins, four draws, two defeats, ten points. Eight scored, nine conceded. The unbeaten opening six had substance; the successive 2–0 losses to Chelsea and Arsenal exposed its limits. This is a season with a route forward, rather than one already pointing in a single direction.

Hard to beat has to lead somewhere

The first six league games brought wins over Palace and Ipswich and draws with Bournemouth, Manchester United, Spurs and Hull. There is value in that resistance. There is also a cost when four afternoons end with one point each. Everton have yet to win away in the league, and the two recent defeats left us without a league goal since Hull on 11 October.

Our view: the next step is to carry more of a threat without becoming easier to play through. Another body arriving beyond the ball changes the question for a defence. Hackney’s first Everton goal, from Barry’s cross, was a useful example on Thursday. Barry then scored himself. A centre-forward can look rather less isolated when he has somebody to find.

Pickford still matters at the other end. One cup scoreline does not settle the argument about Everton’s attacking balance, but it gives Moyes a performance to build on and a selection decision to make. Hackney had only made two previous starts for the club. His third has earned him a serious place in the conversation.

The manager, the coverage, the argument

In his Newcastle programme notes, Moyes identified finishing as a problem in the Chelsea and Arsenal defeats. That is the manager’s diagnosis, not a claim that those games were secretly victories on points. Good work has to turn into shots and goals often enough to change a result.

The contrast in Grand Old Team’s cup report is telling: attention turns from a pair of league defeats to keeping a tangible cup ambition alive. Sky’s match record confirms Garner, Hackney and Barry as the scorers, with Dan Burn replying late. Progress is the headline; the late concession is still there in the small print.

Before the tie, Harry from The Toffee Blues told NUFC Blog’s opposition interview that he would choose cup progress over Monday’s league points. He also described impatience with the season and concerns about defending. That is one identified supporter’s view, not a vote of every Blue. It does capture a recognisable demand: give us something to chase beyond being safely present in May.

Hackney’s own post-match interview puts the relief in context. He called this an important night after the two defeats and spoke about trying to take a chance after time on the bench. A cup run gives those selection arguments consequences. We can enjoy that without declaring every problem repaired by breakfast.

Newcastle again. Different address, different job.

Next comes Newcastle away, Monday 2 November, 8pm GMT, followed by Coventry at home, Friday 6 November, 8pm GMT. Those are the rearranged dates. Thursday’s result earns no credit on Monday’s scoreboard, and a familiar opponent has just had a very direct explanation of what hurt them.

Moyes has already raised the awkward Thursday–Monday–Friday sequence. Rotation will be a football decision with a short recovery window, not a referendum on whether the cup matters. Hackney has made his case; the manager now has to fit the best parts of Thursday into a side capable of winning league games too.

A useful January begins before January

By the new year, we want more support around Barry, a midfield that contributes goals and reliable combinations in the wide and full-back positions. Those are performance requirements before they are a transfer shopping list. The Nørgaard fitness update on 23 October was a reminder that adding an experienced name and having him ready to help are different stages of the same job.

Beyond Christmas, the standard should be a side that can turn draws into wins and keep a cup opportunity alive. Fleetwood have earned their quarter-final, including a win over Arsenal; nobody at Everton has enough spare glory to treat that trip casually. Ten league points call for work. Three cup goals give us a little lift while we do it. Sound. More of the second, please.

Matchday: latest team news, results and discussion →